Merge "Extend ResolverTest.BrokenEdns to cover using EDNS0 for cleartext DNS"... (f66e91b1) · Commits · e / os / android_packages_modules_DnsResolver

tests/resolv_integration_test.cpp

+61 −25

Original line number	Diff line number	Diff line
		@@ -2486,10 +2486,21 @@ TEST_F(ResolverTest, BrokenEdns) {
		typedef test::DNSResponder::Edns Edns;
		enum ExpectResult { EXPECT_FAILURE, EXPECT_SUCCESS };

		// Perform cleartext query in off mode.
		const char OFF[] = "off";

		// Perform cleartext query when there's no private DNS server validated in opportunistic mode.
		const char OPPORTUNISTIC_UDP[] = "opportunistic_udp";

		// Perform cleartext query when there is a private DNS server validated in opportunistic mode.
		const char OPPORTUNISTIC_FALLBACK_UDP[] = "opportunistic_fallback_udp";

		// Perform cyphertext query in opportunistic mode.
		const char OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS[] = "opportunistic_tls";

		// Perform cyphertext query in strict mode.
		const char STRICT[] = "strict";

		const char GETHOSTBYNAME[] = "gethostbyname";
		const char GETADDRINFO[] = "getaddrinfo";
		const char ADDR4[] = "192.0.2.1";
		@@ -2497,6 +2508,9 @@ TEST_F(ResolverTest, BrokenEdns) {
		const char CLEARTEXT_PORT[] = "53";
		const char TLS_PORT[] = "853";
		const std::vector<std::string> servers = {CLEARTEXT_ADDR};
		ResolverParamsParcel paramsForCleanup = DnsResponderClient::GetDefaultResolverParamsParcel();
		paramsForCleanup.servers.clear();
		paramsForCleanup.tlsServers.clear();

		test::DNSResponder dns(CLEARTEXT_ADDR, CLEARTEXT_PORT, ns_rcode::ns_r_servfail);
		ASSERT_TRUE(dns.startServer());
		@@ -2529,33 +2543,47 @@ TEST_F(ResolverTest, BrokenEdns) {
		return StringPrintf("%s.%s.%s.", mode.c_str(), method.c_str(), ednsString);
		}
		} testConfigs[] = {
		// In OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS, we get no answer if the DNS server supports TLS but not EDNS0.
		// Could such server exist? if so, we might need to fallback to query cleartext DNS.
		// In OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS, if the DNS server doesn't support EDNS0 but TLS, the lookup
		// fails. Could such server exist? if so, we might need to fix it to fallback to
		// cleartext query. If the server still make no response for the queries with EDNS0, we
		// might also need to fix it to retry without EDNS0.
		// Another thing is that {OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS, Edns::DROP} and {STRICT, Edns::DROP} are
		// commented out since TLS timeout is not configurable.
		// TODO: Uncomment them after TLS timeout is configurable.
		{OFF, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_UDP, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_FALLBACK_UDP, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{STRICT, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OFF, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_UDP, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_FALLBACK_UDP, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_FAILURE},
		{STRICT, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_FAILURE},
		{OFF, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_UDP, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_SUCCESS},

		// The failure is due to no retry on timeout. Maybe fix it?
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_FALLBACK_UDP, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_FAILURE},

		//{OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_FAILURE},
		//{STRICT, GETHOSTBYNAME, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_FAILURE},
		{OFF, GETADDRINFO, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_UDP, GETADDRINFO, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_FALLBACK_UDP, GETADDRINFO, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS, GETADDRINFO, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{STRICT, GETADDRINFO, Edns::ON, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OFF, GETADDRINFO, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_UDP, GETADDRINFO, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_FALLBACK_UDP, GETADDRINFO, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS, GETADDRINFO, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_FAILURE},
		{STRICT, GETADDRINFO, Edns::FORMERR_ON_EDNS, EXPECT_FAILURE},
		{OFF, GETADDRINFO, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_SUCCESS},
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_UDP, GETADDRINFO, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_SUCCESS},

		// The failure is due to no retry on timeout. Maybe fix it?
		{OPPORTUNISTIC_FALLBACK_UDP, GETADDRINFO, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_FAILURE},

		//{OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS, GETADDRINFO, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_FAILURE},
		//{STRICT, GETADDRINFO, Edns::DROP, EXPECT_FAILURE},
		};
		@@ -2581,13 +2609,18 @@ TEST_F(ResolverTest, BrokenEdns) {
		ASSERT_TRUE(mDnsClient.SetResolversWithTls(servers, kDefaultSearchDomains,
		kDefaultParams, ""));
		EXPECT_TRUE(WaitForPrivateDnsValidation(tls.listen_address(), false));
		} else if (config.mode == OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS) {
		} else if (config.mode == OPPORTUNISTIC_TLS \|\| config.mode == OPPORTUNISTIC_FALLBACK_UDP) {
		if (!tls.running()) {
		ASSERT_TRUE(tls.startServer());
		}
		ASSERT_TRUE(mDnsClient.SetResolversWithTls(servers, kDefaultSearchDomains,
		kDefaultParams, ""));
		EXPECT_TRUE(WaitForPrivateDnsValidation(tls.listen_address(), true));

		if (config.mode == OPPORTUNISTIC_FALLBACK_UDP) {
		// Force the resolver to fallback to cleartext queries.
		ASSERT_TRUE(tls.stopServer());
		}
		} else if (config.mode == STRICT) {
		if (!tls.running()) {
		ASSERT_TRUE(tls.startServer());
		@@ -2630,6 +2663,9 @@ TEST_F(ResolverTest, BrokenEdns) {

		tls.clearQueries();
		dns.clearQueries();

		// Clear the setup to force the resolver to validate private DNS servers in every test.
		ASSERT_TRUE(mDnsClient.SetResolversFromParcel(paramsForCleanup));
		}
		}